My presentation at Holy Trinity put seven of the most common Christian Zionist assertions to the Biblical test. I liken Christian Zionist theology to a balloon of hot air. How many pins do you need to burst a balloon?
My presentation gives seven. Any one will burst the balloon.
At Balmain Uniting Church I was asked to talk about the personal cost of advocacy for Palestine.
I outlined the typical strategy used by the Hasbarafia to discredit critics of Israel’s human rights record.
Get alongside your opponent and try and turn them, buy them, befriend them, bring them on-side. If that doesn’t work move to level 2.
Don’t like what they are saying or writing? Then bombard them with emails, letters and phone calls. Put them on the defensive. Intimidate them with accusations of anti-semitism, holocaust denial, etc. If that doesn’t work, move to level 3.
If you can’t stop them, isolate them. Limit the damage they can do by making them a pariah. Intimidate others by smearing them with ‘guilt-by-association’, with accusations or insinuations. If necessary, threaten to withdraw any funding provided in #1. If that doesn’t work move to level 4.
Associate them with criminal activity, with sex abuse, terrorism, incitement, anything to arouse the interest of the authorities. If that doesn’t work, consider level 5, incarcerate.
Kevin Miller (one of the brilliant script writers for With God on our Side) is working on an expanded list:
1. Ignore — they always start by hoping you’ll just go away.
2. Insult — if you don’t go away, they’ll ridicule you or make you out to be a nut.
3. Intimidate — when simple mockery fails, the gloves come off and they bombard you with emails.
4. Isolate — then they seek to divide and conquer by intimidating others to isolate you.
5. Incriminate — they frame or smear you and force you to defend yourself with legal fees.
6. Incarcerate — when all else fails, as judge and jury, they put your life in the crosshairs.
Like many others, I have the bruises from the first five and I know a few who have made it further for speaking out for justice, peace and reconciliation. You can read more in the Hasbara Handbook here
I also gave a refutation of the political agenda of Christian Zionism drawing on the Jerusalem Declaration on Christian Zionism signed by the heads of churches in Jerusalem in 2006, which I had helped draft. Susan Wahhab, a Palestinian from Ramallah now living in Australia also spoke about her experiences. The church building doubles as a cafe during the week. A great idea!